Welcome to Odd Fellows Cafe

232 Water St, New Shoreham, RI 02807, United States

General Info

Tucked along the waterfront at 232 Water St, New Shoreham, RI 02807, Odd Fellows Cafe is the kind of coffee shop that quickly becomes part of your morning routine. The location feels relaxed and welcoming, which is exactly what you want from a neighborhood spot where locals and visitors gather for a reliable breakfast and good coffee. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere feels casual and easygoing, making it a comfortable place to start the day.

The first thing many people notice on the menu is the coffee selection, especially the Iced Coffee, which has become one of the standout choices here. On warmer mornings, it’s refreshing and smooth, pairing perfectly with the café’s breakfast offerings. Alongside the coffee, the Breakfast Smoothies are another favorite. They’re light, flavorful, and ideal if you want something energizing without feeling too heavy before a day exploring New Shoreham.

Breakfast is clearly the focus at Odd Fellows Cafe, and it shows in the simple but satisfying menu options. One item that keeps showing up in positive reviews is the Ham and Egg Sandwich. It’s a classic combination, served warm and filling, and it hits the spot when you’re craving a traditional breakfast. Another staple is the Bagel, which many guests enjoy with their coffee for a quick but tasty start to the morning. Together, these dishes make the café’s breakfast lineup approachable and reliable.

Service here is straightforward and convenient. Guests can enjoy onsite services, making it easy to relax inside the café with a cup of coffee and breakfast. For those on the move, delivery is also available, which adds flexibility for anyone staying nearby. The focus on breakfast service means the kitchen keeps things moving quickly during busy morning hours, so you can grab your food without a long wait. Even payment is smooth and modern, thanks to NFC mobile payments, which makes checking out fast and simple.

Because of its central location on Water Street, Odd Fellows Cafe naturally attracts both regulars and travelers looking for a dependable coffee shop. Reviews often highlight the comfortable atmosphere and the straightforward menu that focuses on doing a few things well. If you’re walking through the area early in the day and looking for a place to grab a bagel, sip iced coffee, or enjoy a quick breakfast sandwich, this spot fits right into the rhythm of New Shoreham mornings.

Odd Fellows Cafe Photos 2
HOUR OPENING
  • Monday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM
  • Tuesday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM
  • Wednesday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM
  • Thursday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM ,
    04:30 PM - 06:00 PM
  • Friday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM
  • Saturday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM
  • Sunday
    07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Odd Fellows Cafe Photos

Icon

What customers say?

“ This is a fun spot right on the harbor front in New Shoreham on Block Island. The pastries are made fresh on site every morning. I had a raspberry tart that was delicious and made me want a second one. Coffee was very good and the service was fast and friendly. I didn’t get to try the hot items on the menu but everything looked and smelled yummy. If the weather is nice you can sit outside and watch the boats and people come and go. I’ll be back! ”

- Curt Milton -

“ Their cranberry lemon tart bars were amazing. They make all of their offerings in house and they are fantastic! It was even gluten free, I'm not, but it didn't taste any less good. Amazing if you get the chance, stop in and get one, or two! ”

- Jordan Wagner -

“ Super friendly service and delicious breakfast sandwiches. My English Muffin was toasted just right and my wife loved the croissant sandwich. Good iced coffee and can't beat the location. Will have to try lunch next time because all those sandwiches sound great as well! We sat on the porch for an hour people watching with our breakfast post-ferry, gotta love it. ”

- Michael Kelly -

“ Great coffee, smoothies (my kids had to go back for the best smoothie ever), awesome people. Upstairs seating area is so beautiful, creative and whimsical- we ended up staying much longer, lots of good memories here. (My matcha latte was perfect. It’s hard to find unsweetened version at Starbucks or Peet’s.) ”

- Kristen Dority -

“ This is a very convenient spot to grab a coffee and pasty before you hop on the ferry to leave Block Island. The whole milk latte and chocolate croissant I had were pretty good. I’d strongly recommend budgeting at least 15-20 minutes to obtain your food and drink here. ”

- Andrew Zullo -

“ Amazing food! We got the chicken Philly and Marty. My husband and I loved our food so much, we traded each other the second half just to see if the other got just as good of a meal...and we did. My son got a pretzel dog and my mother got broccoli chowder soup. Honestly, the best food I've had in a long time and not that pricey. I believe we paid about 38 for everything. ”

- Melissa Damon Hayes -

“ Odd Fellows Cafe, located on Block Island, is a nice cafe located right off the main street across from the port. I ordered an iced coffee, which was tasty. There is a nice patio that overlooks the harbor, which made for a quick rest spot as we were exploring the island on bikes. Plus, the staff was friendly. ”

- Chris Trethewey -

“ I’ve never seen this cafe before and I was recovering from an Easter bender and needed some caffeine before trudging through Block Island sound on the way back to the mainland. This was the best metaphorical Easter egg that I could hope to find! Great spot, friendly staff, and amazing iced coffee/food. Thanks to you Odd Fellows! ”

- Jeff McHugh -
Banner

Location & Contact

call to book a table & delivery:
information Odd Fellows Cafe:

232 Water St, New Shoreham, RI 02807, United States

Right Now :

See more food places

Pizza delivery
Mesogion 197, Neo Psichiko 115 25, Greece
Restaurant
17100 N Laurel Park Dr, Livonia, MI 48152, United States
Seafood restaurant
29285 Southfield Rd, Southfield, MI 48076, United States
Vegetarian restaurant
122 St John St, Launceston TAS 7250, Australia
Cafe
1737 Kamizaimokucho, Kanuma, Tochigi 322-0065, Japan